Skip to content
Demo
Company 6 min read

Flat rate vs actual cost for EV home charging: AER or real cost in 2026

HMRC Advisory Electricity Rate or actual cost? Compare tax treatment, fairness and cost for company EV home charging, with a worked example for UK fleets.

Aubin Aycaguer, Chief of Staff, Voltaback17 Jun 2026

Side-by-side comparison of flat-rate and actual-cost reimbursement for company EV home charging

For a UK company car charged at home, there are two tax-free ways to pay the driver back: the HMRC Advisory Electricity Rate (AER) of 7p per business mile, or the actual cost of the electricity the car used. A round-sum monthly allowance tied to neither is the risky third option.

The AER is simple but averaged: it overpays drivers on cheap overnight tariffs and underpays those on standard rates. Actual cost pays exactly what the car used and, because HMRC exempts it for private miles too, it gives employers more room. Its only drawback, admin, disappears once measurement is automated.

Flat rate vs actual cost: the short answer

Use the AER when you want a simple per-mile rule and already capture business mileage. Use actual cost when you want each driver paid exactly what their car used, with an audit trail, and the option to cover private charging tax-free.

Avoid a fixed monthly allowance that is not linked to business miles or evidenced cost: it does not benefit from either exemption and is generally treated as earnings, taxed and subject to National Insurance.

Criteria

Round-sum allowance

AER (per business mile)

Actual cost

How it works

Fixed monthly sum per driver

7p per business mile charged at home, 15p if charged publicly

Exact kWh delivered to the company car at home, at the driver's real tariff

Tax treatment

Generally taxable earnings

Tax-free on business miles

Exempt under s.239 ITEPA, business and private miles

Accuracy

Guesswork

National average, revised quarterly

Matches the real cost to the penny

Private miles

Not distinguished

Not covered

Can be covered, still tax-free

Fairness

Penalises high users

Favours cheap tariffs, penalises standard rates

Everyone is paid what they spent

Evidence needed

Hard to justify

Business mileage log

Proof the payment covers only the company car

How the AER works

The AER is part of HMRC's advisory fuel rates. Since 1 September 2026 it is 7p per mile for home charging and 15p per mile for public charging, and it is reviewed every quarter, on 1 March, 1 June, 1 September and 1 December. Source: HMRC advisory fuel rates.

  • It applies only to company cars, and only to business miles. Ordinary commuting is not business travel.
  • When a journey has been powered by both home and public charging, HMRC accepts a fair and reasonable split of the mileage between the two rates.
  • You can pay more than the AER, but only if you can show that the actual cost per mile is higher.

How actual cost works

HMRC does not treat electricity as a fuel, so there is no car fuel benefit charge on an electric company car. When an employer reimburses the electricity used to charge a company car at home, the s.239(2) ITEPA 2003 exemption means there is no separate tax charge, for business and private mileage. Source: HMRC EIM23900.

The one condition is that the reimbursement is solely for the company car. The household's own consumption must be left out, which is why you need to isolate the car's kWh rather than look at the household bill.

In practice that means the kWh delivered to the car, multiplied by the driver's tariff. Tariffs vary a lot: the Ofgem price cap sets an average of 26.32p per kWh from October to December 2026, while overnight EV tariffs published by UK suppliers cost a fraction of that: 6.66p per kWh on EDF GoElectric (11pm to 6am), 8p on Intelligent Octopus Go and 13.33p on OVO Charge Anytime, all checked on 21 October 2026. Sources: Ofgem energy price cap, EDF GoElectric, Intelligent Octopus Go, OVO Charge Anytime.

Who wins and who loses with the AER

HMRC builds the AER on an average efficiency of 3.59 miles per kWh, weighted across company car sales of the last three years, and a home electricity cost of 24.47p per kWh. At that efficiency, 7p per mile is the same as paying about 25p per kWh. Source: HMRC advisory fuel rates.

  • A driver on the capped standard rate of 26.32p per kWh spends about 7.3p per mile and receives 7p, so they are slightly out of pocket on every business mile.
  • A driver on an overnight EV tariff, such as 8p per kWh on Intelligent Octopus Go, spends about 2.2p per mile and keeps the difference.

That difference is not always a flaw: some employers like that a fixed rate rewards drivers who choose a cheap tariff. But it means the AER is rarely the right figure for any given driver, and it never covers private miles.

When a flat rate is tempting but risky

  • Pilot fleets: a handful of EVs feels too small to justify a process. But a pilot is exactly where you should validate the method you will scale.
  • No home data: if you cannot see kWh, the AER feels like the only option. In 2026 that is a tooling choice, not a fact.
  • Payroll simplicity: one rate per mile is easy to run, but it still needs a business mileage log, and drivers on standard tariffs will notice they are subsidising the company.
  • Round-sum allowances: a generous fixed sum keeps drivers happy until they see it taxed on their payslip.

Worked example: a 40-car fleet

The tariffs are real, the fleet is illustrative. Take 40 drivers, each covering 10,000 business miles a year charged at home, so about 2,800 kWh per car at HMRC's 3.59 miles per kWh.

Paid at the AER, each driver receives £700 a year, so £28,000 for the fleet.

Now assume half the drivers are on Intelligent Octopus Go at 8p per kWh and half on the capped rate of 26.32p. At actual cost, the first group costs about £223 each and the second about £733 each, so about £19,120 for the fleet. Sources: Intelligent Octopus Go, Ofgem energy price cap.

Actual cost saves around £8,900 a year, and the 20 drivers on the standard rate are no longer about £33 a year out of pocket. If you also decide to cover private charging, it stays tax-free under the same exemption.

Why actual cost wins with the right tooling

The historical case for a flat rate was never accuracy, it was effort: actual cost meant chasing bills and trusting spreadsheets. Software removes that.

Voltaback is a 100% software actual-cost platform. It reads each home charging session from the car's own data, so only the company car is counted, prices it at the driver's real tariff, charging losses included, and issues a monthly statement per vehicle that gives payroll a clean record and HMRC an audit trail.

The calculation has been audited by an independent third party with a 1.22% average relative error. More than 200 companies rely on it, including 20% of France's largest companies such as Equans, BNP Paribas, Lyreco and Sodexo. There is no hardware to buy, nothing to configure per vehicle, and it works on any home setup.

Once actual cost is automated, the main argument for a flat rate is gone, and you keep the fairness, the control and the audit trail. For the full mechanics, see home charging reimbursement and the home charging blind spot.

Questions about flat rate and actual cost home charging

Written by Aubin Aycaguer, Chief of Staff at Voltaback. Voltaback is a 100% software platform that tracks and reimburses home charging for company EV fleets at actual cost, with no hardware.

If you are choosing between the AER and actual-cost reimbursement, book a demo and we will model the cost difference on your own fleet.