Skip to content
Demo
Company 19 min read

Total cost of ownership of an electric fleet in Europe: the 4-year calculation, electric vs diesel

How to calculate the TCO of an electric fleet in Europe: formula, 4-year electric vs diesel table, cost per 100 km and the national tax layer.

Aubin Aycaguer, Chief of Staff, Voltaback9 Nov 2026

Finance team comparing the four-year total cost of ownership of electric and diesel company cars on a spreadsheet

On a 4-year, 100,000 km cycle, an electric company car and a diesel car cost almost the same to the company before taxes linked to the benefit in kind, and the gap opens after them. In the reference model of this guide the electric car costs €39,880 and the diesel €40,385, a difference of about €500 or 0.40 € per km for both. In a country such as Belgium, where the employer pays a CO2 contribution on every company car, the same model gives €41,912 against €52,896, a gap of almost €11,000 per car.

That is the central point of a fleet total cost of ownership (TCO) in Europe: the vehicle and energy lines are almost the same everywhere, the tax lines are national, and the result of the comparison depends on both. This guide gives the formula, a transparent 4-year model with its assumptions, the cost per 100 km by way of charging, the national layer for nine countries, the variables that tip the result, the hidden costs that spreadsheets forget, and six levers to reduce the TCO of an electric fleet.

The figures are illustrative, in euros, net of recoverable VAT and before corporation tax. Replace each assumption with your own quotes: the method matters more than the totals.

What total cost of ownership means for a fleet

The TCO of a vehicle is everything it costs the company between delivery and return, expressed over the whole period and divided by the distance. It answers a question that the purchase price or the monthly rental cannot: which vehicle is cheaper to run for the way my drivers use it?

Two ideas make the exercise useful in practice.

  • TCO is a comparison tool, not a forecast. It is valuable because the same method is applied to the electric car and to the combustion car. A systematic error, such as ignoring the cost of infrastructure, affects both sides differently and misleads the decision.
  • TCO is a policy tool. A company that sets its car policy by the monthly rental alone will systematically prefer the combustion car, whose rental is lower, even where the electric car is cheaper to own. A TCO model exposes the lines that move the decision, and shows who controls them: finance for depreciation and tax, the fleet manager for energy, maintenance and charging.

For an international group, the TCO has an extra purpose: it makes countries comparable. The same car does not cost the same to the company in Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium or the UK, and the difference comes almost entirely from taxes and employer charges.

How to calculate fleet TCO: the formula

The formula applies to each vehicle, then to the whole fleet:

TCO = financing (rentals, or depreciation and interest) + energy + charging installation + maintenance and tyres + insurance + annual taxes + employer charges linked to the benefit in kind + management costs, minus recoverable VAT.

To compare vehicles that drive different distances, divide the total by the kilometres. The result is the cost per kilometre, the indicator fleet managers follow.

Component

What it contains

Who controls it

Financing

Operating lease rentals, or purchase price minus resale value plus financing cost

Finance and procurement, at the order

Energy

Electricity at home and in public, or fuel

Fleet manager and drivers, every day

Charging installation

Reinforced socket or wallbox at home, equipment at the site

Fleet manager, with the driver

Maintenance and tyres

Servicing, tyres, repairs outside the lease

Fleet manager and provider

Insurance

Premium for the vehicle

Procurement and risk

Annual taxes

Road tax, registration tax where it is not in the rental

Finance, set by national law

Employer charges on the benefit in kind

Social contributions or national contributions linked to the private use of the car

HR and finance, set by national law

Management costs

Tools, administration, driver support

Fleet manager

Recoverable VAT

Deducted from each line, within national limits

Finance

Five errors distort most TCO calculations:

  1. Comparing different durations or mileages. Use the same pattern of use for both vehicles.
  2. Comparing rentals only. In the example below, the rental of the electric car is 67 % of its TCO, and the other lines decide the result.
  3. Ignoring VAT and employer charges. Remove the recoverable VAT and add the charges linked to the benefit in kind.
  4. Assuming that every electric car charges at home. At public rapid charging prices, 100 km in an electric car cost as much as in a diesel.
  5. Forgetting the charging installation where the driver is expected to charge at home. A suitable electrical circuit is still needed, and only the connected charger can be avoided.

The reference model: assumptions

The example is a compact car of the C segment, with the same mileage for both powertrains. Every figure is a round number representative of Western European quotes in 2026.

  • Duration and distance: 48 months and 100,000 km (25,000 km a year).
  • Operating lease rental, excluding VAT: €560 a month for the electric car and €490 for the diesel. The €70 gap is typical of a compact car today and is the first assumption to check with your lessor.
  • Maintenance and tyres outside the lease: €35 a month against €55, because the electric car has fewer wear parts.
  • Insurance: €90 a month against €75, because repairs cost more on an electric car.
  • Consumption: 21 kWh per 100 km at the plug, charging losses included, against 5.5 litres per 100 km.
  • Energy price: €0.25 per kWh at home, €0.50 on the public network, and a weighted price of €0.30 per kWh with 80 % of the charging at home; diesel at €1.75 a litre excluding recoverable VAT.
  • Charging installation: €500 on average per electric car, for an installation sized to the need (reinforced socket, existing circuit or a simple wallbox).
  • Annual road tax: €50 for the electric car and €250 for the diesel, an average of rates that range from zero to several hundred euros depending on the country.
  • Benefit in kind and its employer charges: excluded from the base model and added country by country in a later section.

Three points about the method change the result and deserve to be stated.

  • The home price of €0.25 is the marginal price of a kWh, that is energy, per-kWh network fee, per-kWh taxes and VAT, and not the average price of a household bill that includes fixed fees. In Belgium the night price is about €0.24, in Germany the Destatis household average is about €0.32, and in the Netherlands a typical all-in price is €0.25 to €0.30.
  • The public price of €0.50 is an average between public AC charging at around €0.46 and rapid charging at €0.60 to €0.73 in the Netherlands, so it is slightly optimistic for rapid charging.
  • The rental gap of €70 a month weighs €3,360 over four years. It is the first assumption to check, and it is not stable: residual value forecasts for electric cars have moved sharply in recent years.

Electric vs diesel over 4 years: the full table

With these assumptions and 80 % of the charging done at home:

Line (4 years, net cost to the company before corporation tax)

Electric

Diesel

Difference

Rentals

€26,880

€23,520

+ €3,360

Maintenance and tyres

€1,680

€2,640

− €960

Insurance

€4,320

€3,600

+ €720

Energy

€6,300

€9,625

− €3,325

Home charging installation

€500

€0

+ €500

Annual road tax

€200

€1,000

− €800

TCO before employer charges on the benefit

€39,880

€40,385

− €505

Cost per km

€0.40

€0.40

about €0.005

Reading the table: the electric car costs more in rental and insurance, and recovers on energy, maintenance and tax. The balance is close to zero. The electric car is not systematically cheaper before the tax layer, and it is not more expensive either. Which side wins depends on three variables that the company controls or can negotiate: the rental gap, the share of home charging and the national treatment of the benefit in kind.

What 100 km cost, depending on how you fuel

The price of a kWh varies by a factor of three according to where the driver charges, and this single variable explains most of the differences between fleets.

Way of fuelling

Price

Cost per 100 km

Home, night tariff

€0.20 per kWh

€4.20

Home, standard marginal price

€0.25 per kWh

€5.25

Home, typical household average (Germany)

€0.32 per kWh

€6.72

Public AC charger

€0.46 per kWh

€9.66

Public rapid DC charger

€0.60 to €0.73 per kWh

€12.60 to €15.33

Diesel

€1.75 per litre

€9.63

At home, 100 km cost between €4 and €7, about half the diesel. On a public AC charger the electric car costs about the same as the diesel. On a rapid charger it costs more. A driver who charges mostly in public pays more per kilometre than the same driver in a diesel, and the TCO of the fleet moves accordingly. This is why the share of home charging is the single variable to manage and measure.

The national layer: taxes, benefit in kind and VAT

The base model excludes three items that are set by national law: the road tax (included here as an average), the benefit in kind and the employer's charges on it, and the VAT and deductibility rules. These are the lines that make the same car cost different amounts in different countries.

Country

Employer-side effect of an electric company car

Main reference

Germany

Low: a benefit of 0.25 % of the list price a month, no specific CO2 charge on the employer; trade-tax add-back on leasing

Benefit in kind by country

Netherlands

No employer charge on the bijtelling; the driver pays tax on 18 % to 22 % of the catalogue price

Benefit in kind by country

Belgium

Monthly CO2 solidarity contribution, at a low minimum for an electric car, and a deductibility rate that depends on the order date

Depreciation rules by country

Luxembourg

Flat-rate benefit of 0.5 % or 0.6 % a month; the energy is understood to be included

Leasing or buying

Switzerland

0.9 % a month, with the employer's share of social contributions; same rate for all powertrains

Benefit in kind by country

UK

Class 1A National Insurance of 15 % on the benefit: low for an electric car

UK site

Spain

Social contributions on the valuation, reduced by 30 % for electric cars

Benefit in kind by country

Italy

The fringe benefit at 10 % of the ACI table feeds payroll contributions

Benefit in kind by country

Portugal

Social security on 0.75 % of the acquisition cost, and no autonomous taxation under the conditions in the lease guide

Leasing or buying

For a precise TCO in a given country, the national layer is added on top of the base. Two examples show the order of magnitude.

Belgium: the CO2 contribution

In Belgium the employer pays a monthly CO2 solidarity contribution to the social security office for every company car. For a car ordered since 1 July 2023, an electric car pays the minimum amount, about €42 a month in 2026, while a diesel emitting 120 g/km pays about €261 a month, and about €358 in 2027 once the multiplier rises to 5.5.

Over four years that is about €2,032 for the electric car and €12,511 for the diesel. Added to the base model, the TCO becomes €41,912 for the electric car and €52,896 for the diesel, a gap of €10,984 per car. The contribution is the largest single reason why electric company cars are cheaper than diesel in Belgium, and it is an employer charge, so it is invisible in a comparison of rentals.

United Kingdom: Class 1A National Insurance

In the UK the employer pays Class 1A National Insurance at 15 % on the taxable benefit. For a £45,000 car, the 2026/27 benefit is £1,800 for an electric car (4 %) and £16,650 for a car taxed at 37 %, so the employer's Class 1A is about £270 against about £2,498 a year. Over four years the difference is about £8,900 per car in favour of the electric car, before the benefit moves up to 9 % by 2029/30. The UK site details the figures.

What tips the result: sensitivity

A TCO is only as good as its three or four sensitive assumptions. In the reference model, the results move as follows.

Variable

Change

TCO of the electric car

Gap with the diesel (before employer charges)

Reference

80 % home at €0.25

€39,880

electric cheaper by €505

All charging at home

100 % home at €0.25

€38,830

electric cheaper by €1,555

Night-tariff drivers

Weighted price €0.244

€38,704

electric cheaper by €1,681

Little home charging

30 % home

€42,505

electric dearer by €2,120

No home charging

0 % home, all public at €0.50

€43,580

electric dearer by €3,195

Larger rental gap

Electric rental €675 instead of €560

€45,400

electric dearer by €5,015

Three findings stand out.

  1. Home charging is worth about €3,000 to €4,700 per car over four years. Going from 0 % to 80 % of charging at home moves the result by about €3,700, and from 30 % to 80 % by about €2,600.
  2. The rental gap is worth more than the energy. A €115 higher monthly gap changes the result by €5,520. A lessor's offer deserves more attention than a charging contract.
  3. The national layer often exceeds both. In Belgium the contribution alone is worth about €10,500 per car over four years, which is why the first question for any country is what the employer's charges on the benefit are.

Home charging: the line that is most often wrong

Energy is the most variable line of the TCO, and the one the fleet manager controls the least from the office. Three mistakes recur.

  • Not knowing where the cars charge. If nobody measures the split between home and public charging, the company discovers it in the expense reports, when drivers claim public charging or rapid charging on long trips.
  • Reimbursing at a flat rate that does not match real cost. A flat monthly amount over-pays drivers on cheap night tariffs, who then have no incentive to charge at the cheapest hours, and under-pays drivers on expensive contracts, who have an incentive to use public chargers on the company's card.
  • Not reimbursing at all. The driver pays about €700 to €1,500 a year for the company's car, which sooner or later becomes a complaint, a turnover cost or a move to a public charging card at three times the price.

The method that closes the gap is the same everywhere: measure the kWh that went into the company car, price them at the driver's real contract, reimburse the result, and keep a statement per car. Voltaback does it in software, from the car's own data, with no hardware to buy. Voltaback relies on the home's MID-certified meter, not on a standalone cable meter, and its calculation has been audited by Bureau Veritas with a relative error of 1.22 %. Our guide to reimbursing home charging explains the risk of the alternatives.

Lease, purchase and the residual value

The financing line is usually the largest, and the part of it that the company controls least is the residual value. In an operating lease the lessor takes the residual value risk and includes its estimate in the rental. In a purchase, the company keeps the risk.

For electric cars the uncertainty is higher than for diesel, because second-hand prices depend on battery health, charging speed and the pace of new models. A rental that looks high may hide a cautious residual value, and a rental that looks low may hide a mileage limit or a state-of-health condition at return.

Three practical rules for the TCO:

  1. Compare quotes on the same terms: same duration, same mileage, same services, same excess-mileage price.
  2. Test the result with a worse residual value, for example 5 points lower, to see whether the decision holds.
  3. Add the tax effect of the form of financing. Accelerated depreciation in the UK, Germany and Spain makes buying more attractive for a limited time, and Belgium makes the date of the lease a condition. See our guides to leasing or buying and depreciation.

From one car to a fleet: what the model means at scale

A gap of a few hundred euros per car looks small, and it is multiplied by the size of the fleet. For 50 electric cars in the reference model, the difference with diesel before employer charges is about €25,000 over four years in favour of the electric cars. In a country where employer charges favour the electric car, as in Belgium, the same 50 cars produce a gap of about €549,000. The reverse also holds: if the rental gap is €115 a month higher than assumed, the 50 cars cost about €250,000 more than 50 diesel cars.

Three consequences for a fleet manager.

  • The decision is made at the level of the whole fleet, not car by car. Some roles suit an electric car perfectly: short daily distances, a garage at home, predictable routes. Others suit a diesel or a hybrid for another cycle, such as very long motorway distances without access to rapid charging. A TCO by vehicle category tells which is which.
  • Savings come from managing, not from choosing once. The same electric fleet can cost 10 % more or 10 % less depending on the share of home charging, the tariffs of the drivers and the way the reimbursement is built.
  • Variance between drivers matters. Averages hide a long tail: a few drivers who charge only in public can account for a large share of the energy line. A statement per car shows them.

Distance: a small effect, in favour of the electric car

The more a car drives, the more its lower cost per kilometre matters. In the reference model, every additional 10,000 km over four years costs about €630 in electricity at the weighted price and about €960 in diesel, so about €330 in favour of the electric car. The effect is real but modest, and it disappears if the extra kilometres are done on rapid chargers. For high-mileage roles, the share of home charging counts more than the distance.

Plug-in hybrids and vans

A plug-in hybrid has the vehicle costs of both powertrains and the energy cost that depends entirely on whether it is charged. A plug-in hybrid driven mostly on petrol can cost more to run than a pure diesel, and its tax rate is converging with that of combustion cars in several countries, as the benefit-in-kind guide shows. A TCO for plug-in hybrids needs a measured share of electric kilometres, not an assumption.

For vans, VAT is usually recoverable in full and the benefit in kind does not apply to a vehicle that is not used privately, so the tax layer is lighter and the TCO depends on energy, maintenance and the lease. The same method applies with its own assumptions.

How to build the model in six steps

  1. Define the scope. Which vehicles, which countries, which duration and which annual distance.
  2. Collect the quotes. Two lease offers for each vehicle on the same terms, with the lines separated: finance, maintenance, insurance, taxes.
  3. Set the energy assumptions. The marginal price of a kWh at home for each country, a public price, the consumption in real use and the share of home charging.
  4. Add the national layer. Road tax, the benefit in kind and the employer's charges on it, deductibility and the recoverable share of VAT, with the date that applies to each rule.
  5. Test the sensitive variables. Rental gap, home share, tariff, residual value and distance.
  6. Check with real data after six months. Replace the energy assumptions with the measured kWh and prices, and update the model.

The last step is the one that makes a TCO a management tool instead of a one-off study. A company that measures its charging has the real data, and not an assumption, to put into the next order.

The hidden costs of a fleet TCO

Some costs do not appear in a lessor's quote and are missing from many spreadsheets.

  • Unmanaged charging. Without data, the company cannot tell whether a plug-in hybrid is ever plugged in, and a plug-in hybrid that is not charged runs on petrol with an extra battery to carry.
  • Public charging on the company card. A driver whose home cannot charge uses a card at €0.50 to €0.73 per kWh, which can double the energy line for that driver.
  • Downtime and administration. Charging, fines, tolls and expense reports take time, and the cost of managing them is rarely counted.
  • Tyre wear. Electric cars are heavier and have strong torque, and tyres can wear faster than the quote assumes.
  • Charging infrastructure at the site. A connection upgrade can cost more than all the charge points put together. See our guide to workplace charging installation.
  • Charging losses. The energy lost between the plug and the battery, usually 10 % or so, is part of the cost and must be in the consumption figure, as it is in the model above.
  • Policy changes. Benefit rates, caps and deadlines are revised often. A TCO that assumes this year's rate for the whole lease can be wrong by year three.

A note on corporation tax

The model stops before corporation tax, because the deductibility of a car varies widely: 100 % for rentals of a zero-emission car in the UK, a ceiling by emissions or by date in Belgium, a proportion that depends on the use of the car in Italy. Corporation tax usually reduces the cost of both vehicles by a similar share, so it changes the totals more than the gap, except where the deductibility rules differ by powertrain. In that case, as in Belgium, run the model twice, before and after tax, and look at both gaps.

Six ways to reduce the TCO of an electric fleet

  1. Measure where each vehicle charges. The share of home charging is the variable with the largest effect that the company can influence. Track it by driver and by month.
  2. Reimburse home charging at real cost. It aligns the company's cost with the actual consumption, removes the over-payment on cheap tariffs and lets drivers keep the benefit of a good tariff only when it is real. Our charging policy template shows how.
  3. Encourage off-peak charging. A night tariff or a dynamic tariff can bring the price below €0.20 per kWh. A policy that pays at real cost lets the driver keep the incentive, since the saving reduces the company's cost directly.
  4. Negotiate the lease with the TCO in mind. Ask for two offers on the same terms, separate the lines, and test the residual value.
  5. Follow eco-driving and maintenance. Smooth driving and correct tyre pressure reduce consumption and wear. See our guides to eco-driving and maintenance alerts.
  6. Size the charging infrastructure to the need. A reinforced socket on a dedicated circuit supplies enough for overnight charging in many cases, and costs a fraction of a connected charger. See our guide to the price of a home charger.

The European framework points the same way. The CO2 standards for new cars, the Clean Corporate Vehicles proposal of December 2025 and the charging requirements for buildings under the recast EPBD all increase the share of electric vehicles that companies will buy, and in several countries the tax advantage will narrow by 2030. A TCO model that is updated every January keeps the decision in line with the rules in force.

A TCO checklist for a multi-country fleet

  1. Use the same distance, duration and services for every vehicle compared.
  2. Remove recoverable VAT, and keep the irrecoverable share.
  3. Add the employer's charges on the benefit in kind for each country.
  4. Fix the price of a kWh at the marginal price, and test a night tariff and a public price.
  5. Test the share of home charging at 30 %, 80 % and 100 %.
  6. Test the rental gap and the residual value.
  7. Include the charging installation, and the connection if it has to be upgraded.
  8. Update the model each January and at each new order.

Questions about the total cost of ownership of an electric fleet

Measure the energy line to control the TCO

The energy line is the one a fleet can change every month. Voltaback measures home charging per vehicle, reimburses it at actual cost and shows the split between home and public charging, with no hardware. Book a demo or estimate your own figures with the home charging cost simulator.

Recommended articles